Three Days of Summer Reading Recommendations: Day 1 – The Dunderheads by Paul Fleischman, illustrated by David Roberts

by Tom B.

We’ve spent a lot of time in the library this summer (insane heat will do that) and, as a result, my list of books that I’m aching to recommend keeps getting bigger and bigger. I literally have a notebook where I write down frantic notes like “Must share this with new dads!” or “Best zoo book ever? Have to tell people!” (I can’t decide if that behavior is enthusiastically earnest or borderline psychotic. I should probably ask my wife.) But the fact that I sometimes decide to write 3,000 words on a certain comic book series I particularly like – thank you again for your patience, dear readers – means that I have a pretty huge backlog of books that I’m anxious to recommend. So, as I prepare to spend a week away at a lovely little cottage by a lake, I wanted to call out three fairly amazing picture books that have been on my radar lately that I think are perfect for any bored early reader looking for something interesting to read this summer.

Quick word of warning – None of these books are recently published titles and at least one of them seems to be out-of-print, so this list isn’t about “hot new reads that just came out for Summer 2012!” These are just three books that happened to fall into our realm of interest recently, largely thanks to our local library and some friendly recommendations.

The Dunderheads

Your favorite heist movie conventions wonderfully packaged for kids.

So, for the next three days, I’ll be sharing one pick per day, starting today with…. The Dunderheads (2009) by Paul Fleischman, illustrated by David Roberts.

The Dunderheads is the picture book equivalent of a really smart, really entertaining, big-budget summer movie. And it’s a wonderful example of an author finding a great way to have some character-driven fun with genre conventions. In the past, I’ve discussed how, before my daughter was born, I was a little obsessed with how I would introduce her to classic fairy tales and folk tales. I was adamant that we had to have copies of all the canonical legends of the past, so I could teach her about all of the big storytelling archetypes, myths, tropes, and idioms that she’d be encountering as a new reader. In my mind, I thought, “How can she know when a picture book is riffing on Cinderella if she hasn’t read Cinderella yet?” While that turned out to be way less of a problem than my fevered “new dad brain” thought it would be, I’ve remained really aware of how my daughter has been introduced to new genres and story types through her reading.

We picked up The Dunderheads at the recommendation of a librarian and, little did I know, that it would serve as my daughter’s introduction to one of my favorite genres of all time – THE HEIST GENRE. That’s right, The Dunderheads is a heist movie for kids in picture book form, and it revels in playing with all of the glorious “heist movie” details, tropes, and quirks that any even casual film fan knows by heart. The Dunderheads was written by Paul Fleischman, a Newbery-winning author and poet, and gloriously illustrated by David Roberts (whom you may remember from Iggy Peck, Architect), and it’s apparent that both creators are having a blast with their “heist caper for kids” adventure. In the jacket copy, the creators of The Dunderheads reference Steven Soderbergh’s Ocean’s Eleven movies and it’s a totally apt comparison. This is a story about a kid putting together a team to right a wrong by stealing something back from a bad guy, and its creative influences seemingly come much more from classic movies (the Ocean’s movies, The Italian Job, The Thomas Crown Affair, The Great Muppet Caper) than classic literature.

The Dunderheads

Every good heist movie needs a scrounger…

Well, that might not be entirely true. The Dunderheads does come across like a gleeful hybrid between a heist movie and a Roald Dahl school story. A horrible teacher named Miss Breakbone (a seeming descendant of Dahl’s Mrs. Trunchbull from Matilda) despises her students and refers to them as “the dunderheads.” But, when Miss Breakbone crosses the line and cruelly confiscates a ceramic cat that one of her students, a skilled trash scrounger known as Junkyard, intended to give to his mother, the “Dunderheads” organize to steal it back. Like in a heist movie, the Dunderheads are primarily defined by their areas of specialty. The group is organized by a kid called “Einstein” – he’s the brains of the operation. He formulates a plan to break into Miss Breakbone’s house to steal the cat back and recruits a team of classmates with the skills to pull the job off. There’s Wheels (his transportation man), Nails (a kid with lock-picking fingernails), Spider (who can climb anything), and a whole host of others. My personal favorite Dunderhead is Hollywood, an obsessed film fan who hilariously advises the team on “what would happen right now if this was a heist movie.”

The Dunderheads

How could you NOT want to rob a teacher like this?

The Dunderheads

Having a character in a heist story who’s an expert on heist stories is genius.

I had a blast reading this with my daughter. She thought it was a riot and it felt like I was giving her a primer on one of my favorite film genres. It’s a longer picture book – 56 pages – with significant text on some of the pages, which makes it a fantastic transitional read to bridge that gap between picture book and chapter book (particularly if your younger child is just starting to show interest in chapter books). And there’s a recent sequel too – The Dunderheads Behind Bars – that’s almost as good as the original. The Dunderheads is the best heist movie you’ll read to your kid this summer.


Do you have any recommendations for some fun, non-traditional summer reads? If so, share them in the comments section below.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Luanne November 7, 2013 at 5:17 pm

I just discovered your website and have marked it as a favorite. I am a grandmother that wants to get good books for our grandchildren. I was so happy to discover your list of “princess” books and plan to get one for my granddaughter for Christmas.
I am wondering if you have suggestions for 4-year-old boy. I would like to get him a “hero” book that is not too preachy but is about a good hero as opposed to many bad heros.
Thanks – keep up the wonderful suggestions.

Tom B. November 7, 2013 at 10:34 pm

Hi Luanne,

Thanks for your kind comment.

If you’re looking for a fun book about heroes for a young boy, here are a few titles that I think could work well:

First, The Astonishing Secret of Awesome Man, a really fun picture book by novelist Michael Chabon and illustrator Jake Parker:

The Woods by Paul Hoppe, a picture book about a boy venturing out to save his stuffed animal:

Giants Beware by Jorge Aguirre and Rafael Rosado, a wonderful graphic novel about a group of kids venturing out to fight giants:

or Frankie Pickle and the Closet of Doom by Eric Wight, a fun graphic novel/chapter book hybrid about a boy with a hyperactive imagination:

Hope those help!

Previous post:

Next post: